院外心肺复苏中电除颤波形选择的Meta分析:单相和双相

梁镰静; 李东泽; 万智

doi:10.13201/j.issn.1009-5918.2019.03.002

院外心肺复苏中电除颤波形选择的Meta分析:单相和双相

- 四川大学华西医院急诊科急诊医学研究室四川大学灾害医学中心(成都, 610041)

详细信息

通讯作者: 万智,E-mail:935623842@qq.com

中图分类号: R541.7

收稿日期: 2018-12-16

Defibrillation waveform selection in out-hospital patients during CPR:biphasic vs.monophasic

- Department of Emergency, West China Hospital of Sichuan University, Chengdu, 610041, China

More Information

Corresponding author: WAN Zhi, E-mail: 935623842@qq.com

Received Date: 16 December 2018

摘要

摘要: 目的:探讨院外心肺复苏中双相波及单相波电除颤对患者预后的影响。方法:系统检索Pubmed (1966-2016.12), EMBASE (1980-2016.12) 数据库, Cochrane临床研究注册中心 (CENTRAL) (建库至2016.12), 并网络检索及手工检索相关文献。纳入所有关于对比院外心肺复苏时双相波及单相波电除颤患者预后的随机对照研究及前瞻性队列研究。分析不同波形电除颤对患者的自主循环恢复情况 (ROSC), 入院时存活率, 出院时存活率, 1个月存活率以及出院患者神经系统恢复情况的影响。结果:纳入4篇RCT文献及3篇前瞻性队列研究文献。院外心肺复苏时双相波与单相波电除颤在ROSC上差异无统计学意义 (RR=1.11, 95%CI:0.91~1.36, P=0.32, I²=65%), 入院存活率 (RR=0.94, 95%CI:0.67~1.32, P=0.72, I²=76%), 出院存活率 (RR=1.14, 95%CI:0.84~1.54, P=0.40, I²=0), 1个月存活率 (RR=1.13, 95%CI:0.98~1.32, P=0.10, I²=70%) 以及生存患者神经系统恢复情况 (RR=0.95, 95%CI:0.75~1.21, P=0.69, I²=0) 均差异无统计学意义。结论:虽然目前指南推荐使用双相波电除颤, 但目前证据表明院外心肺复苏时使用双相波或单相波电除颤, 患者预后差异无统计学意义。
- 心肺复苏 /
- 电除颤 /
- 双相 /
- 单相 /
- meta分析
Abstract: Objective: To systematically review the prognosis of biphasic and monophasic waveform defibrillation in out-hospital patients with cardiac arrest.Method: We searched Pubmed (1966-2016.12), EMBASE (1980-2016.12) and CENTRAL (create detebase-2016.12), and retrieved of all the researches which compared the prognosis of biphasic and monophasic defibrillation in out-hospital patients.The outcomes including:return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC), survival at hospital admission, survival at discharge, 1-month survival, and neurologic recovery in discharged patients.We pooled the original results of included studies by using standard random effects, yielding a weighted hazard ratio (RR) and a 95% confidence interval (95%CI).Result: According to the retrieval strategy.Finally, a total of 4 RCT literature and 3 prospective cohort studies were included.ROSC have no significant difference between biphasic and monophasic waveform (RR=1.11, 95%CI:0.91-1.36, P=0.32, I²=65%).The survival rate of admission (RR=0.94, 95%CI:0.67-1.32, P=0.72, I²=76%), the survival rate after discharge (RR=1.14, 95%CI:0.84-1.54, P=0.40, I²=0), 1-month survival (RR=1.13 95%CI:0.98-1.32, P=0.10 and I²=70%) and nervous system survival recovery (RR=0.95 95%CI:0.75-1.21, P=0.69;I²=0) also had no significant difference.Conclusion: The use of biphasic and monophasic wave electric defibrillation had no significant difference on the prognosis in patients with out-of hospital CPR.
- cardiopulmonary resuscitation /
- electrical defibrillation /
- biphasic /
- monophasic /
- meta analysis

HTML全文

参考文献(22)

[1]	张在其, 骆福添, 陈兵, 等.我国八个大中城市院前急救流行病学调查分析[J].中国急诊医学杂志, 2010, 19 (11):1130-1136.
[2]	刘成杰, 关紫云, 李晚泉, 等.不同波形自动除颤仪在院外心肺复苏中的疗效比较[J].中国急救医学, 2012, 32 (7):606-610.
[3]	高蕴雅, 龚镇楠, 朱伯良, 等.低能量心脏除颤心肌损伤的实验研究[J].中国心脏起搏与心电生理杂志, 2001, 15 (2):113-115.
[4]	Koster RW, Sayre MR, Botha M, et al.2010 International consensus on cardiopulmonary resuscitation and emergency cardiovascular care science with treatment recommendations, part 5:adult basic life support[J].Resuscitation, 2010, 81 (1):E48-E70.
[5]	Perkins GD, Travers AH, Berg RA, et al.Part 3:A-dult basic life support and automated external defibrillation:2015 International Consensus on Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiovascular Care Sciencewith Treatment Recommendations[J].Resuscitation, 2015, 95:e43-69.
[6]	Jadad AR, Moore RA, Carroll D, et al.Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials:is blinding necessary?[J].Controll Clin Trials, 1996, 17 (1):1-12.
[7]	Loc KL, Mertz D, Loeb M.Newcastle-Ottawa Scale:comparing reviewers' to authors' assessments[J].BMC Med Res Methodol, 2014, 14 (1):45.
[8]	Schneider T, Martens PR, Paschen H, et al.Multicenter, randomized, controlled trial of 150-J biphasic shocks compared with 200-to 360-J monophasic shocks in the resuscitation of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest victims[J].Circulation, 2000, 102 (15):1780-1787.
[9]	van Alem AP, Chapman FW, Lank P, et al.A prospective, randomised and blinded comparison of first shock success of monophasic and biphasic waveforms in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest[J].Resuscitation, 2003, 58 (1):17-24.
[10]	Morrison LJ, Dorian P, Long J, et al.Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest rectilinear biphasic to monophasic damped sine defibrillation waveforms with advanced life support intervention trial (ORBIT)[J].Resuscitation, 2005, 66 (2):149-157.
[11]	Kudenchuk PJ, Cobb LA, Copass MK, et al.Transthoracic incremental monophasic versus biphasic defibrillation by emergency responders (TIMBER)[J].Circulation, 2006, 114 (19):2010-2018.
[12]	Kajino K, Iwami T, Berg RA, et al.Comparison of neurological outcomes following witnessed out-of-hospital ventricular fibrillation defibrillated with either biphasic or monophasic automated external defibrillators[J].Emerg Med J, 2009, 26 (7):492-496.
[13]	Tanabe S, Yasunaga H, Koike S, et al.Monophasic versus biphasic defibrillation for pediatric out-of-hospital cardiac arrest patients:a nationwide populationbased study in Japan[J].Critical Care, 2012, 16 (6):R219.
[14]	Goto Y, Maeda T, Funada A, et al.Comparison of biphasic and monophasic waveform defibrillations in out-of-hospital cardiac arrest:An observational cohort study[J].European Heart J, 2015, 36 (3):206-207.
[15]	Faddy SC, Powell J, Craig JC.Biphasic and monophasic shocks for transthoracic defibrillation:a meta analysis of randomised controlled trials[J].Resuscitation, 2003, 58 (1):9-16.
[16]	Sunde K, Jacobs I, Deakin CD, et al.Part 6:Defibrillation:2010international consensus on cardiopulmonary resuscitation and emergency cardiovascular care science with treatment recommendations[J].Resuscitation, 2010, 81 (1):e71-e85.
[17]	Weisfeldt ML, Becker LB.Resuscitation after cardiac arrest:a 3-phase time-sensitive model[J].Jama, 2002, 288 (23):3035-3038.
[18]	Tang C, Wang P, Gong Y, et al.The effects of second and third phase duration on defibrillation efficacy of triphasic rectangle waveforms[J].Resuscitation, 2016, 102 (1):57-62.
[19]	Leng CT, Paradis NA, Calkins H, et al.Resuscitation after prolonged ventricular fibrillation with use of monophasic and biphasic waveform pulses for external defibrillation[J].Circulation, 2000, 101 (25):2968-2974.
[20]	Walcott GP, Killingsworth CR, Smith WM, et al.Biphasic waveform external defibrillation thresholds for spontaneous ventricular fibrillation secondary to acute ischemia[J].J Am College Cardiol, 2002, 39 (2):359-365.
[21]	Gazmuri RJ, Kaufman CL, Baetiong A, et al.Ventricular Fibrillation Waveform Changes during Controlled Coronary Perfusion Using Extracorporeal Circulation in a Swine Model[J].PLoS One, 2016, 11 (8):e0161166.
[22]	Viana MA, Bassani RA, Petrucci O, et al.Rapidly switching multidirectional defibrillation:Reversal of ventricular fibrillation with lower energy shocks[J].J Thoracic Cardiovascul Surg, 2014, 148 (6):3213-3218.